China has been working for years to spy its way to AI dominance

China has been working for years to spy its way to AI dominance

Shane Harris writes:

Jensen Huang is the kind of target that spies dream about. Intelligence agencies work for years to develop a source who can get so close to such a powerful man. That the former Nvidia CEO is also friends with Donald Trump makes him even more valuable. Viewed one way, the Huang operation is painfully simple: It demonstrated the power of human-intelligence gathering and the weakness of the male ego, one Western official told me, somewhat admiringly.

Much remains unknown about how China’s Ministry of State Security might have enlisted Alice Huang (no relation), who was having an extramarital affair with the tech titan, or what information she might have provided. Chinese officials have dismissed the U.S. allegations that she is an MSS asset as baseless smears, and U.S. officials have not presented the evidence they believe shows her affiliation. But experts on China’s intelligence tactics told me that she was probably not a trained operative who set out to entrap the Nvidia boss. More likely, they said, the MSS learned she was having an affair with Huang and then recruited her. Under China’s National Intelligence Law, citizens are required to assist the MSS when asked. And the agency doesn’t always ask nicely. MSS officers are known to coerce potential assets by threatening to seize their property or harassing their family members, former officials told me.

For more than four decades, China has relentlessly stolen U.S. secrets—in cyberspace, outer space, and in the flesh. China’s hackers tend to get the most attention because they have penetrated countless computer networks, vacuuming up commercial and official secrets and laying the groundwork to potentially cripple communications systems in the event of a war with the United States. But China’s spymasters have also created an extensive human network, recruiting business executives, university professors, students, and even an educator in California who later became mayor. “China is going after technology and innovation as part of a national strategy to develop their economy and strengthen their national security,” David Cohen, the former deputy director of the CIA, told me.

Beijing is acutely focused on AI as it navigates its rivalry with the U.S., one that has led American military planners to warn about the outbreak of a potential war. China’s president, Xi Jinping, has called for “an explosion of original and disruptive innovations” in AI and other fields, including quantum computing and biotech.

If a case officer were to make a list of who has the most influence over the development of AI and the rules governing it, Huang would have been at the top—at least until this week. “He’s not a surprising target,” Connor Forman, a former China analyst at the CIA, told me. “He has insight into the company and U.S. policy aims, needs, and goals. He’s of tremendous value to a nation-state, beyond chips.” The MSS would presumably have been looking for any avenue it could find into Huang’s world. Alice Huang “may have just been the right person in the right place at the right time” to provide the access that the MSS wanted, Forman said.

“I’m not at all surprised by it. This is what China does,” Alan Kohler, the former head of counterintelligence for the FBI, told me. “Someone hit a home run here, because the target was Jensen Huang. But China is also likely targeting dozens of low-level engineers that no one has ever heard of at Nvidia and other tech companies.” [Continue reading…]

Comments are closed.