Findings, music, and occasional reflections by Paul Woodward

Search

Sharing

Facebooktwittermail

Follow

rss

Paywalls

Frustrated by following links to articles you can’t continue reading? Learn more, here, here, and here.

Categories

Archives

Recent Posts

The poison in Britain’s Labour Party

 

In a letter to The Observer, Howard Jacobson, Simon Sebag Montefiore, Sir Simon Schama, Neil Blair, Tracy-Ann Oberman, and Rabbi Julia Neuberger, write:

Over the past four years, we have watched the unchecked spread of vicious antisemitism – anti-Jewish racism – in the Labour party with bewilderment and disgust – all the more so since we respected Labour’s long previous history of fighting racism, and its many brave and decent members.

Now, after the BBC’s Panorama programme, we can see for ourselves what is and isn’t false. The extent of Labour’s antisemitism, the degree to which it has been protected, sanctioned and propagated by the leadership faction, can brook no further denial. It is clear this is not just about Jeremy Corbyn but the pernicious world view of a faction that has – temporarily, we hope – taken control of Labour.

But yet again the Labour leadership remains determined to go on piously protesting its innocence, rejecting the message and blaming the messenger.

We are where we were before. Whistleblowers would be heroes to any other Labour party; to this Labour party they are traitors.

In our view, those whistleblowers and Labour members who could no longer stomach what was happening in a party they loved, and were in some cases driven to the point of nervous breakdown by it, have shown a rare moral courage and decency that belongs in a great tradition, and gives us hope. In the meantime, trust between Corbyn’s Labour and most Jews in Britain appears to be fractured beyond repair. The very fact that Labour is, like the BNP before it, being statutorily investigated by the Equality and Human Rights Commission for racism is not a matter of housekeeping, but a taint of international, historic shame.

There are procedures that could take the heat out of this – a fully independent complaints body, for example, over which Corbyn and his inner circle exert no covert influence. Not with the aim of shuffling off blame, but in order, finally, that the party will honestly own up to what can no longer be filed away in a folder. After Panorama, damage limitation should not be the first priority for Labour. Draining the antisemitism that lies like a pool of poison in the party’s soul is. Now, nothing else will do.

A few years ago, there was some legitimacy to the claim that some supporters of Israel were cynically engaged in hasbara when they conflated criticism of Israel with antisemitism.

In 2009, the Israeli filmmaker, Yoav Shamir, released his documentary, Defamation, in which he exposed the efforts of organizations such as the Anti-Defamation League in the U.S., to amplify concerns over antisemitism where evidence of its actual extent was commonly being overstated.

Ten years later, if Shamir was to revisit the same issue, he would be forced to tell a very different story.

What changed?

There are multiple strands to the growth of anti-Jewish hatred, but the one that afflicts the Labour Party can surely be traced above all to the popularization of the so-called pro-Palestinian movement.

I say “so-called” because what was long a political movement supporting the self-determination of a population living under military occupation, has in recent years metastasized by becoming, at least for some of its non-Palestinian supporters, less pro-Palestinian and more anti-Israeli.

In 2011, President Obama’s ambassador to Belgium, Howard Gutman, was harshly criticized for stating the obvious: that Israel’s military actions targeting Palestinians were fueling the rise of antisemitism.

Gutman said that “throughout the Muslim communities that I visit, and indeed throughout Europe, there is significant anger and resentment and, yes, perhaps sometimes hatred and indeed sometimes an all too growing intimidation and violence directed at Jews generally as a result of the continuing tensions between Israel and the Palestinian territories and other Arab neighbors in the Middle East…every new settlement announced in Israel, every rocket shot over a border or suicide bomber on a bus, and every retaliatory military strike exacerbates the problem and provides a setback here in Europe for those fighting hatred and bigotry here in Europe.”

Hostility towards Israel rose dramatically during the 2008-09 war on Gaza and was further reinforced by a widely condemned economic siege that continues to this day.

But along the way, it became clear that for many people concerned with this issue, their sense of injustice and outrage increasingly expressed itself more through antipathy directed at the perpetrators of this injustice rather than as solidarity with its victims.

When Palestinians in Yarmouk outside Damascus suffered just as egregiously as those in Gaza, the pro-Palestinian movement largely remained silent.

The equivocations commonplace among supporters of Israel who are reluctant to criticize the actions of its government, were echoed by antiwar and anti-imperialist activists who were reluctant to condemn the actions of Assad and his Russian and Iranian allies — lest such criticism might imply support for a long-predicted Western intervention in the war in Syria.

Where there was no shortage of self-ascribed moral clarity in viewing the conflict between Israelis and Palestinians, the conflict between a brutal dictatorship and its opponents was supposedly far too complex for Middle East watchers to reliably decipher.

As Elizabeth Tsurkov wrote last year:

For the past two weeks, horrifying images of Palestinians being murdered have surfaced on social media. Jets have dropped bombs, sending flames and black smoke into the air, followed by helicopters dropping improvised and unguided barrel bombs. On the ground, in the besieged Palestinian camp, buildings collapsed burying civilians alive underneath them.

Those who have attempted to flee the camp have been arrested. No food or medicine has been allowed into the camp since July 2013. About 200 residents have starved to death or died due to lack of medicine. The airstrikes and shelling have not stopped for two weeks, preventing rescuers from retrieving the rotting corpses.

And yet, despite these horrors, no significant protests took place anywhere in the West or Arab world. The traditional champions of the Palestinian cause — those same people who have protested Israeli attacks on Gaza — have remained silent as the Palestinian Yarmouk refugee camp near Damascus in Syria was shelled by Russian and Syrian air forces, while militias loyal to the Assad regime enforced a brutal siege.

The silence surrounding the brutalization of an entire Palestinian population exposes something few have spoken about: that pro-Palestinian sentiment is often just anti-Israel or anti-American sentiment dressed up in disguise. And when it comes to Syria’s starving, dying Palestinian population, the pro-Palestine left is nowhere to be seen.

There is a larger theme here with echoes across the political spectrum. It involves the exploitation of the easiest route for galvanizing political unity: that is, rather than trying to articulate and advance political goals, it’s much easier to identify and vilify a common enemy. Everyone can instantly stand together when they agree about who they stand against.

It’s a ploy that works just as well for protest leaders or presidents, populists or dictators.

Politics based on opposition, whatever its radical trappings, has a tendency of reinforcing the status quo. It’s all about taking a self-righteous stance, rather than moving forward and taking the risk of stumbling as you go.

But the politics of the common enemy all too easily creates common ground with the likes of Saddam Hussein, Muammar Gaddafi, Bashar al-Assad, and Vladimir Putin.

For Jeremy Corbyn and his close advisers, their habitual political reflex is to regard every challenge as an enemy assault.

What they are finding too hard if not impossible, is to acknowledge their own role in enabling the growth of a malignancy that is now destroying their own party.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Facebooktwittermail
rss

5 Replies to “The poison in Britain’s Labour Party”

  1. Steve says:

    Not only offers soccer gambling and sports activities betting games, Betberry is
    usually also one of the most trusted Joker123 agents in Indonesia that is usually chosen by millions of betting fans every day.

    With all the Trusted Joker123 Agent, you may enjoy hundreds of
    unique games from the on line casino, slot and game classes that are currently very popular with players on the planet, namely shooting fish.

    You need to know that Joker123 or Joker Gaming is one of the biggest online bookies in Asia,
    that has dished up millions of players with international standard games in addition to operates under official permit.

    On the site joker123 also provides various varieties of casino gambling and slot games, as nicely as fish shooting or even fish hunter games of which are their mainstay video games.

    Not only a complete game, Joker123 also arrives with attractive features like
    the following:

    Live Casino Joker123
    For those of you who else want to feel a new sensation in actively playing casino gambling, with the particular official Joker123 agent Betberry
    you may play gambling reside! This implies you will become
    playing in a real-time casino gambling system and served by beautiful dealers that you can socialize
    with. Not only the playing casino gambling, yet here you also acquire the atmosphere like actively playing in a gambling residence directly in Vegas!

    Joker123 Online Slots
    Many individuals choose joker123 slot wagering since the game is straightforward and doesn’t require a large amount
    of effort like casino video games or soccer betting.
    Yet a game won’t become fun whether it doesn’t consist of challenges, right?
    At typically the Trusted Joker123 Agent you can challenge yourself
    in order to reach the biggest modern jackpot where the number regarding jackpots will always boost each time until the participant can get it.

    Take the Joker123 fish
    This specific one is a fairly brand new game but has previously
    attracted the attention of millions of gambling gamers all over the
    world. Feel the thrilling sensation of playing shooting fish with
    abundant prizes. In this game a person will not play only because game can be played by up
    in order to 8 players concurrently. Demonstrate your skills and accomplish maximum
    victory in the game Fish Hunter Joker123.

  2. My brother recommended I may like this blog. He was entirely right.
    This post truly made my day. You cann’t imagine just
    how much time I had spent for this information! Thank you!

  3. You should take part in a contest for one of the finest blogs on the web.
    I will highly recommend this website!

  4. Alternate Links to Official Online Gambling Sites

    Now in a good all-sophisticated era, everyone could access the
    internet very very easily. Until now many
    free games that can be played by everyone, one example is online gambling online games.
    With the appointment regarding gambling that used to be
    able to be only on land, now an online method has made it very easy for many gambling players to channel their hobbies and
    interests in the world regarding online gambling.

    When you want to play wagering which is now online method.
    You still have to learn typically the characteristics
    of trusted on-line gambling sites. Why is usually that?
    Because in the online world there usually are still gambling online sites that cheat.

    Meaning of Alternative Backlinks
    An alternative link will be a link provided by a trusted online gambling real
    estate agent to prevent blocking whenever you want
    to get into or access their internet site.

    How to Get Alternative Hyperlinks
    When you currently know the meaning of different links, we will offer
    some steps to get alternative links:
    1. You can look at the main internet gambling sites. Usually
    these people will provide alternative hyperlink info to their site.

    2. The second step will be to be able to directly contact Livechat, an individual can directly ask typically the customer service on responsibility
    3. You can see an alternative link in order to your trusted online wagering site
    through the listing of on the internet gambling sites below.

  5. S128 Indonesian Cockfighting Site

    Betting games that are very attached to the hearts of
    Indonesian people are known as s128 cockfight gambling. Looking in Indonesia’s historical
    record, cockfighting games have existed even since the days of the kingdom.
    This activity is not only entertainment but is also
    part of a lifestyle passed down through decades of Indonesian ancestors.

    Unfortunately, although this activity is a cultural heritage of thousands of years, the particular
    Indonesian government does not discriminate in enforcing the particular law until finally it is quite difficult
    to look for a spot to play cockfighting in Dalam negri.

    Fortunately technology invented the internet because in the modern era
    like now you can again access exciting online games through an internet link.

    Enough with the capital associated with
    electronic devices like laptop computers, computers or
    smartphones connected to the internet, you can immediately enjoy typically the excitement of playing.

    There are indeed many internet gambling sites that offer similar provides on the
    internet, yet unfortunately not every of these types of sites can be trusted.
    Only a handful regarding sites have the ability to provide expert services which are worthy of being obtained by
    consumers as provided by the town of S128 Sabung Chicken breast.

    S1288 or better called S128 has been present for years serving every lover
    of online game cockfight gambling throughout Asia, also the world.
    Hundreds of people are linked every week to enjoy every match that may be presented and you will watch typically the match directly through the available live streaming.

    There are many interesting features that are owned simply by s128 as the greatest
    chicken gambling bookie in Asia. Listed below are interesting functions that you need to know:

    Live loading!
    The first advantage you can get from playing cockfighting is the availability of live buffering chicken battles that are usually
    served in HD or perhaps high definition quality.

    I think very clear to ensure that an individual won’t miss a individual bit of excitement employing S128 as your online gambling partner.

    Various tournaments are available
    There are numerous tournaments that you take portion in on a regular basis so
    simply no need to be afraid you will not get a sport
    because with s128 poultry matches will almost always be present each day and you may take pleasure in the selection of games you want.

    Attractive Bonuses and Marketing promotions
    Customer comfort is a new top priority for us. As a result, this site
    has provided many interesting bonuses in addition to promos
    that you can follow as an recognized member. These bonuses in addition to promos are given since thanks from s128 to be able to
    customers for choosing them as partners to enjoy online gambling.

    How to Play Chicken Gambling on S128
    All you want to do first before starting the game will be to register yourself since a member on the Betberry
    site. It’s easy, visit the official Betberry website and your enrollment menu.
    Complete the sign up process and you will immediately obtain a user ID plus
    password that you will later use to record into the game.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.